|
While these specs are reasonably accurate, remember that just having a higher compression ratio doesn't guarantee better performance. Conventional engine wisdom is not to match dished pistons with chambers designed for flat pistons. The clearances and quench shape will allow the flame kernel to spread away from the spark, instead of being quenched into it. As a result it's easier for the motor to get 'pingy'. Aluminium heads can run higher compression before pinging than iron The highest compression you can use on the street with 93 octane gas is about 10-10.25:1. A quality ignition will help you run higher compression without pinging, as will richening the mixture.
But rather than partake in the "which is best" game, keep in mind that compression aside, using the stock large valves, and ported to hot specs, they all work pretty much the same. Also keep in mind, these heads are approaching 35 years of age and may have been shaved/rebuilt before you got it.
Back in the 1960's when the American car companies wanted to advertise giant horsepower ratings, they hit on a devious method. Instead of testing an engine in a car, they would fine tune it and test it in a climate-controlled room on an engine stand. Under these perfect conditions, with no belts, AC, or powertrain to worry about, these engines would produce much higher horsepower than an engine on the street could hope to reach. Finally the government stepped in the early 1970's, and required that the companies test engines in the car, with AC and other accessories on and measure it at the rear wheels. GROSS HP was the old method, and NET HP is the (more realistic) new one. Subtracting about 20% from GROSS gives you NET. Adding 25% to NET gives you GROSS. During this period (1971-74), between the insurance industry raising rates on high horsepower vehicles and the ecology movement insisting on better emissions, car companies were forced to lower both. So they dropped engine compression, installed emission camshafts, and leaned out the carbs. Naturally because of the new air pumps and hoses, people blamed them for the loss of power. I actually remember people removing hoses and blocking off solonoids on their V-8s thinking they would pick up lost horsepower. Good try, but it was mainly the lower compression and poor carburation that slowed most cars down in the '70s. Even the Z was affected with crappy carbs and air pumps in 1974, while the move to fuel injection on the 280Z has been said to have been more for emissions than performance. Datsun somehow got away with using the old GROSS horsepower rating through 1978, probably since they were an import company. All their cars from 1979 onwards use the NET method for horsepower. So even though '75-77 engines say "170hp" on the little plate in the engine compartment. You notice a little "SAE" (Society of American Engineers) printed there as well...this is a subtle way of saying GROSS.
|
|
|